I have a love/hate relationship with a soap company.
About five years ago, I stumbled across their products online. They boasted rare and unique scents and naturally-sourced ingredients. They were irresistible (to me, anyway). And their prices seemed reasonable.
So, I placed an order. And that’s when my troubles began.
I had to share my email address to complete my transaction. You know, to “receive an order confirmation.”
Within days, I found myself receiving marketing email after marketing email. Coupons. Special sales. New soaps. New scents. Free shipping.
I imagined their marketing department high-fiving one other and saying, “We’ve got one on the line. Quick! Reel her in!”
And you know what? The products I received were exceptional. They smelled amazing (I’m a sucker for a unique scent). So, I stuck it out for a while. But not forever.
Because I knew how wrong my experience was. I knew there was a better way to market your business. A kinder, gentler way — one that doesn’t alienate the very people you want to nurture.
Time went on.
I sent dozens of their catalogs to the landfill — a new one came in the mail every few weeks.
Finally, I gave up. After placing a few orders, I contacted the company and asked them to please — for the Love of All that Is Holy — stop sending me catalogs. I clicked the unsubscribe link in one of their many emails and used the form on their site to let them know why I was unsubscribing.
Then, I stopped hearing from them.
Here we go again: relearning a lesson
A lot has happened in the meantime. Life went on, and I forgot about this company’s overzealous marketing efforts.
A few weeks ago, when my husband asked me what I’d like for Mother’s Day, I said, “How about a gift certificate to (The Soap Company in Question)?” And my husband — smart man that he is — got me the gift certificate.
And guess what? It started all over again. Within just a couple of weeks, I have received three catalogs.
I take full responsibility for the situation. I got myself back on their radar and now I’m paying the price. I do still love their products, but I wish they understood modern marketing techniques as well as they clearly understand the soap business.
It’s obvious to me that they don’t read Copyblogger. Because if they did, they’d know the four basic truths of modern content marketing.
Let’s review them.
Truth #1: Content pulls; it doesn’t push
Rather than blanket prospects in catalogs and crowd their inboxes with sales emails, modern content marketing offers valuable, helpful, and even entertaining information.
The information is so helpful that prospects purposely sign up to receive it. And they stick around when the content they receive is consistently useful.
Read these posts to learn more about creating content that pulls (and doesn’t push):
- How to Attract, Nurture, and Grow the Business-Building Audience You Want
- 5 Remarkable Qualities of Effective Online Content
- 5 Ways to Get More of the Online Attention You Crave
Truth #2: Content offers; it doesn’t demand
Solid, effective content marketing doesn’t stomp its foot and demand in a whiny voice that you pay attention to it.
Instead, it confidently offers a hand — the exact information you need, right when you need it.
One way modern content marketers do this is by using marketing automation.
If my soap company had sent me a little brochure about how to save money on laundry day (and a coupon for their laundry soap), I would have held on to that piece of content. I might have posted it next to my washing machine! It wouldn’t have gone to a landfill like all those product catalogs.
Read these posts to learn more about making offers (not demands):
- Landing Pages: Turn Traffic Into Money
- How to Be a Copywriting Genius: The Brilliantly Sneaky Trick You Must Learn
- 6 Proven Ways to Boost the Conversion Rates of Your Call-to-Action Buttons
By the way, our Rainmaker Platform makes marketing automation a snap. 🙂
Truth #3: Content entertains; it doesn’t annoy
One of the foundational truths about content marketing is that it must serve your audience if you want it to be effective (more on this below).
And one way to do this is to meet your audience — wherever they are — with content that is so compelling they want to consume it.
At Rainmaker Digital, we do just that with our podcast network, Rainmaker FM.
Podcasting isn’t a requirement, but it’s a great fit for those who are comfortable with audio — who are more comfortable talking than writing.
Read these posts to learn more about creating entertaining (not annoying) content:
- The Art of Being Interesting
- 22 Ways to Create Compelling Content When You Don’t Have a Clue [Infographic]
- 58 Ways to Create Persuasive Content Your Audience Will Love
Truth #4: Content is about the consumer, not the producer
Please repeat after me:
“I will resist the urge to constantly write about me, my offers, my company’s history, our goals, our mission statement, or our new products. Instead, I’m going to focus on writing about topics that serve my prospects and customers.”
It’s tough for traditional marketers to wrap their brains around this one. But your customers’ #1 concern isn’t you … it’s them.
That’s why, for example, if the soap company had sent me information about alternate ways to use their soaps (Perfume your pajama drawer! Hang one in your closet! Use it to repel mosquitos!), I would have stayed subscribed.
And an occasional offer woven into the helpful content wouldn’t have fazed me one bit.
A highly effective technique for serving your prospects’ and customers’ ongoing needs is creating a series of cornerstone content pages on your website.
Cornerstone pages serve up foundational information that your prospects and customers need to understand your field of expertise.
Read these posts to learn more about creating cornerstone content pages that serve your audience:
- A Practical Approach to Using Powerful Cornerstone Content on Your Site
- Your Cornerstone Content Blueprint: Answers to 9 Common Questions
- 11 Essential Ingredients Every Cornerstone Content Page Needs [Infographic]
True confession
Here’s the painful truth: I spent the first part of my career creating exactly the kind of marketing materials my soap company is annoying me with now. Direct mail postcards. Sales catalogs. Promotional brochures.
But now I know there’s a better way. A kinder, gentler way to market your business, serve your prospects and customers, and create marketing that is valued, not sent straight to a landfill.
That’s the kind of marketing we teach inside our Authority program. To learn more about it, click the button below.
inside Authority
Reader Comments (29)
Linda says
My bad marketing story: I recently was sent a survey from the New York Times about ad blockers and why I use one. I was blunt with them regarding annoying marketing practices, especially things like multiple video ads on one page that all autoplay at the same time, creating a jumble of sound. As the survey went on, it became clear they really didn’t want my opinion. They were trying to persuade me to unblock the ads. They asked questions like “Does knowing that we make our money based on advertising make you more willing to enjoy the ads?” Yes, they used the word “enjoy”!
Unfortunately, after they got to the whiny part of the survey, they didn’t have any comment blocks so I was unable to tell them that their business model isn’t my problem. If the model based on ads isn’t working, they need to change their model. Sending surveys with questions that sounded more like them whining because those of us with ad blockers weren’t cooperating with that model is not the way to endear themselves with their customers. I wanted to tell them “It’s about us, not you.” 🙂
Pamela Wilson says
Wow, Linda. I’m speechless!
Marketing has changed and it continues to change. If there’s anything I’ve learned after all these years it’s that we can’t resist the changes: we need to move with them and adapt to them, always with the goal of serving the people we want to cultivate as customers.
Thanks for sharing this story. 🙂
Paula Lago says
Great list! I think the main thing to keep in mind first is “The information is so helpful that prospects purposely sign up to receive it” There is nothing more annoying that someone trying so hard to push you do something! And invasive newsletters or catalogs are one of those.
Pamela Wilson says
It’s amazing how quickly advertising becomes helpful information when it’s approached like content.
Iman says
Great article!!
You can only get so far saying ‘buy soap, buy soap, buy soap’ or ‘buy my product, buy my product, buy my product’ before your potential customers are inwardly screaming ‘f*** off!!!!’
Customers want relationships with the brands they buy, a give and take relationship, not yet another source of pressure continually asking for their energy. Customers want to be relaxed and reassured you can take care of their problems, not hounded for a sale.
Great article!
Adam Joshua Clarke says
Great video gallery. These are some of my favorites. Cornerstone content is still one of the strongest key elements to me. In order to rank well you need to prioritize specific content with your structure. I have found that surrounding a topic gets you better search engine results and choosing which pages to treat as the strongest pages let’s you plan around how you want to grow your content.
Mania Mavridou says
It’s great there are posts like this one, to teach us or remind us of those simple truths!
I have unsubscribed from a lot of similar blogs and websites, although I found their content interesting at first.
Reading such kind of posts, sooner or later, we’ll learn how to do it right!
Thanks!
Pamela Wilson says
Glad you enjoyed it! We try to live what we teach around here. 🙂
Matt says
Great article Pamela! I am guilty of the above and funny that you write about it because I was literally just going into my autoresponder to tame things back a few notches 🙂
Pamela Wilson says
Good luck, Matt!
Chloe says
Your article is brilliant. And you model what you talk about. I immediately wanted to sign up for everything you offer and I have flagged this email so I can study it more deeply over time — particularly in relation to my own website, webinars, possible future podcasts. I need to think more deeply about how to market my Resonance Repatterning system for life-change from within. And your article is definitely going to help me. Thank you.
Pamela Wilson says
Thanks so much, Chloe!
Alex says
What a piece.
Thanks Pamela for the hard truth. It’s high time companies change their marketing strategies and think about their customers first.
M. K. Zeppa says
I get annoying frequent emails from companies whose products I’ve purchased…but I just hit delete. And then one day, their otherwise annoying email coincides with my need for something of theirs and cool, I get free shipping or 10% off this time.
Could it be a numbers thing?
Pamela Wilson says
Maybe, M.K., but I don’t know if everyone has the same level of patience you do! I tend to unsubscribe after too many sales pitches.
Sonia Simone says
I think if the relationship is basically sound then to some degree it’s a numbers thing — but you can improve your numbers by not driving people to unsubscribe or, even worse, just mark you as spam.
There can be some ROI in “spray and pray,” but it’s nearly always more effective (not to mention less annoying) to send fewer, more relevant messages — ideally using some automation tweaks to get the right offers in front of the right folks.
Alaura Weaver says
THANK. YOU. You’ve beautifully illustrated the difference between treating prospects as consumers versus treating them as human beings.
As a conversion-focused copywriter, I have to balance the razor’s edge of persuading a reader to take action (often while using time honored sales formulas) and being formulaically salesy. Which is why always, always, ALWAYS understanding the emotional needs and goals of my target keeps me out of that “BUY NOW!!!! (quadruple exclamation point) territory and helps me stay nice & comfy in the “How can I help you?” territory.
Brilliant, bookmarked & Buffered!
Pamela Wilson says
Alaura, thank you. “How can I help you?” territory won’t steer you wrong … even when you’re writing a call to action.
Liz Farr says
Great article, Pamela!
A couple months ago I purchased a series of exercise videos. I was immediately inundated with multiple daily emails from the creator who seemed to invent a new From name for every campaign that went out. After a few weeks of getting spammy-looking emails that I didn’t open because I couldn’t quickly identify the sender, I unsubscribed from the list. Maybe there was other stuff I would have bought? Who knows. They lost me as a potential buyer.
Priya says
That’s a really good reminder. The only person who is excited about launch of a new product/range of services are the only one’s who are going to make money of them. For everyone else it is ‘What’s in it for me?!!’
Anh Nguyen says
Pamela,
I really like your ideas about sending soap tips and tricks instead of a massive amount of catalogues. The funny thing is so few people are doing it, not even the New York Times. As human beings, it’s so hard for us to zone out of ourselves and focus on others.
That’s why those who do immediately stands out from the crowd.
Thanks for sharing!
Cheers,
Anh
Nordie says
I’ve learnt one trick over catalogs: don’t send them to landfill – all that does is fill the landfill and make you keep the rage – the company doesn’t care what you read it or not.
There’s the adage of “hit em where it hurts”, i.e. Money Talks. Send the catalog back to the company who sent them out (“Return to sender”). Don’t put a stamp on it – make them pay for it. Not only do they have to pay to print and send them out, but they have to pay to get them back, then they have to pay to get rid of them.
This has actually worked for me on several occasions for different companies (I never got anything again!)
Sonia Simone says
I’ve actually found it’s quite effective to put your name on the “Don’t mail me catalogs” lists. Smart direct mailers (dumb ones go broke) don’t particularly want to spend large amounts of money sending print material to people who are just going to throw it out.
OTOH, if you buy mail order, that will tend to overwrite that — because they know that if the cover appeals, they have a good shot at your business. The best way to never get catalogs is never to buy anything mail order.
Terry says
What a great post! I was totally captured by your story and felt that I could relate. It got me engaged enough that I consumed the 4 points 🙂 Thanks!
Rohan Bhardwaj says
Beautiful.
I had a similar experience with a clothing website. I bought one product from them and boom, I started receiving emails every week and messages on my phone regarding amazing offers.
The idea that they had offers every week meant they were trying to attract me and it didn’t sound real – maybe a marketing gimmick.
Although I loved their product – I unsubscribed.
I hope many amazing companies follow modern marketing. Loved the post Pamela.
Stay Awesome.
Matthew says
I am more than guilty sadly of “over offering” my clients. I have been slowly learning that it’s not just about pitching stuff and hoping I make money, but actually offering quality content. Thank you for the reminder, I will do my best to change for the better.
Pamela Wilson says
Stick around here, Matthew, and we’ll do our best to keep you inspired. 🙂
Oun says
Could you PLEASE PLEASE get these messages out to marketers everywhere? I get DAILY offers from the clothes company I buy from EVERY SINGLE DAY – sometimes twice a day. Who designs these crazy campaigns? Have they seen any sane person buying clothes everyday?
I delete 99% of the emails and probably go in and buy when the sales are so good – probably because no-one is buying because we’re all turned off by the barrage of emails.
Pamela Wilson says
We’re trying to spread the word! Feel free to help out by sharing this post.
Between you and me, I think the people who design those excessive campaigns drink way too much coffee. 😉
This article's comments are closed.